Guides / Choosing help

"Free website" with a local SEO plan: what's the catch?

By the Twelby team · Updated 2026-11-16
Short answer

Usually the catch is not the price but what happens when you leave. Some agencies register the domain in their own name, keep the site on a platform you can't take with you, or hold ownership of your Google Business Profile. Before signing, get in writing that the domain is registered to you, what happens to the site if you cancel, and that you stay Primary Owner of your listing.

A website included in a monthly local SEO plan is not a trick by itself. Building a site costs an agency time, and many spread that cost across the months you stay. The real question is different: what do you walk away with if you stop paying? That answer lives in a few details most owners never look at until the day they want out.

This guide covers those details, so you can ask about them before you sign, not after. For the wider contract (guarantees, minimum terms, deliverables), see red flags in a local SEO contract. Here we stay on the website, the domain and the Google listing.

Where the catch usually hides

Owners who feel trapped by an agency rarely describe a bad website. They describe a hostage. The plan ends, and they find out that the address customers know, the pages Google has indexed, or the listing with years of reviews is not fully theirs.

There are four separate things to ask about, and each one can be owned by a different party:

An agency can be generous with one and quietly keep another. A "free website" on a domain the agency registered is still their website, and moving to a new address means starting your search history over.

The domain: whose name is on the registration

Every domain has a registrant, the person or company the registration belongs to. ICANN, which sets the rules for domain registrars, calls this the Registered Name Holder. Its Transfer Policy names two parties who can approve or deny moving a domain to another registrar: the Registered Name Holder and the Administrative Contact. In a dispute, ICANN says the holder's authority wins.

In the event of a dispute, the Registered Name Holder's authority supersedes that of the Administrative Contact.

ICANN, Transfer Policy

So the name in the registrant field matters more than who pays the renewal or who "manages" the domain. If an agency registers your domain under its company name, it holds that authority, not you.

Checking is less obvious than it sounds. ICANN's public lookup tool often shows "redacted for privacy" instead of a name, because personal data in registration records may be hidden under privacy rules (ICANN, 2019). The reliable check is the registrar account itself:

An agency can do all the technical work with access you grant to the account, or by having you point the domain at their hosting. Neither requires the domain to be registered in their name.

The site and the content: what you can take with you

The domain is the address. The site is the building. Many agencies build on their own platform or a page builder licensed to them. That is not wrong, but it means the pages may not be portable. When you leave, the site can simply switch off, and the address points at nothing.

Copyright is the other half. Under US rules, the author of a work is ordinarily the person who actually created it. A commissioned work counts as the client's own "work made for hire" only in specific situations, and one of them requires a written agreement (U.S. Copyright Office, 2024). In plain words: text, design and code an agency creates do not automatically become yours because you paid for them. If you want them, the contract should say so. This is general information, not legal advice; a lawyer can read your actual contract.

What you bring yourself (your photos, your service descriptions, your logo) stays yours. Still, ask that it be handed back in a usable form, not locked in a dashboard you lose access to.

Three answers to get before signing:

The Google Business Profile: owner, not manager

Your listing is often worth more than the website. It carries your reviews, photos and history, and it is what most customers see first. Google built a clear structure for sharing it, and the structure tells you exactly what to ask for.

1primary owner per Business Profile, though there can be several owners (Google Business Profile Help, 2026)
7 daysbefore a newly added owner or manager can remove users or transfer primary ownership (Google Business Profile Help, 2026)

According to Google's help page on owners and managers, owners can add or remove users, edit the profile and even delete it. Managers can do almost everything else, but cannot add or remove users or remove the profile. Only owners can remove other owners and managers.

RoleWho should hold itWhat it can do
Primary ownerYouEverything, including removing others
OwnerYou or a partnerAdd or remove users, delete the profile
ManagerThe agencyDay-to-day work, not users or deletion

Manager access is enough for an agency to fix categories, post updates, add photos and reply to reviews. If an agency asks to become primary owner, or asks for your Google password, ask why. When you part ways, you remove a manager yourself. Getting primary ownership back from someone who does not want to give it is a much longer road.

What leaving should look like

The fairest way to judge a "free website" offer is to walk through the exit before the start. Ask the agency to describe the day you cancel, in writing. A fair answer covers each piece:

  1. The domain stays where it is. It is already registered to you, so nothing has to be transferred back.
  2. The site has a clear fate. You either keep it on stated terms, take the files, or point the domain back to a site you already have.
  3. The listing needs one click. You remove the agency's manager access, and nothing else changes.
  4. The work done stays. Pages, articles and listing fixes made while you paid do not vanish with the contract.

Then compare that with the cancellation terms. A long minimum term, a fee to "release" the domain, or a site that disappears on the last day are the usual signs that the website was the lock, not the gift.

Keep this

Five questions to ask before you sign a plan with an included website:

  1. Whose name is in the registrant field of my domain, and do I have the registrar login?
  2. If I cancel, what happens to the site on the first day after?
  3. Who owns the text and design you create, and is that in the contract?
  4. Will I stay Primary Owner of my Google Business Profile, with you as Manager?
  5. How do I cancel, how much notice, and what does leaving cost?

How we handle it at Twelby

Since every paid Get Found plan (Website, Growth and Pro) includes a new website, here are our answers to the same questions, as they stand on our plans page.

That is the whole catch: the new site is hosted by us while you are a client, and keeping it after you leave means staying on the Website plan, $69 a month. We say it before you start, and you can check the rest against the questions above.

If you want to see first who currently owns what on your listing, the free Business Check-Up reads your Google profile and website from the outside.

Check this on your own business

The free 60-second Business Check-Up runs more than 70 checks on your website and Google profile, with your live Maps position next to the businesses Google shows instead of you, and shows where you stand on this: Profile ownership, Indexable pages. Public data only, no login, no card.

Run the free Check-Up

Or we run it for you

We build your new website on your own domain, which stays registered to you, keep your old site untouched, and work on your Google listing as Manager while you stay Primary Owner. Get Found, our done-for-you local SEO service, starts free. Website, $69 a month, gives you a new website, hosted and looked after; Growth, $199 a month, adds SEO and AI search work; Pro, $399 a month, adds your Google profile and every review answered. Try any paid plan free for 5 days, then month to month.

See Get Found

Questions

Is a free website with an SEO plan a scam?

Not by itself. Many agencies spread the cost of building a site across the months you stay. The thing to check is what you keep if you leave: the domain, the site, the content and your Google listing.

How do I check who owns my domain?

Log in to the registrar account where the domain is registered and look at the registrant contact. ICANN's public lookup often hides names for privacy, so the account itself is the reliable place to check.

Should my SEO agency be the owner of my Google Business Profile?

No. Stay Primary Owner and give the agency Manager access. Google's roles let a manager do the day-to-day work but not remove users or delete the profile.

Can I keep the website if I cancel?

It depends entirely on the agency's terms, so ask before you sign. Some sites switch off on the last day, some can be kept for a hosting fee, and some can be handed over as files.

Sources

  1. ICANN: Transfer Policy. icann.org
  2. ICANN: Updated lookup tool for domain name registration data now available, 2019. icann.org
  3. ICANN: Registrants' Benefits and Responsibilities. icann.org
  4. U.S. Copyright Office: Circular 30: Works Made for Hire, 2024. copyright.gov
  5. Google Business Profile Help: Manage your Business Profile owners & managers. support.google.com